Sunday 27 January 2013 

Case: Homicide or Suicide?



DATE: 14 February 2008

SCENE: WOMAN FOUND DEAD IN A CAR WITH ENGINE RUNNING.

NAME: Mary Rose

AGE: 26

TIME FOUND: 10:00

ESTIMATED TIME OF DEATH: 22:00 11 Feb 2008

ESTIMATED DURATION OF DEATH: 12 hours (according to liver temperature)

SUSPECTED CAUSE OF DEATH: Suicide-Carbon Monoxide poisoning

DESCRIPTION OF DECEASED: Death by poisoning- purplish skin, white foam found







 

AUTOPSY REPORT


AUTOPSY REPORT FINDINGS:

DILATED PUPILS
PULMONARY EDEMA
CEREBRAL HYPOXIA
RIGAMORTIS / POSTMORTEM RIGIDITY
CARDIAC ISCHEMIA

FURTHER KIDNEY ANALYSIS:

URINE SAMPLE
-trace amount of aconitine


NOTE: Could it be Aconitine poisoning?

 

Aconite? Aconitum? Aconitines?



WOW ! Beautiful flowers!!!

Let's check it out:
Family: Ranunculcaceae
Scientific name: Aconitum spp
Common name: monkshood
Found in: forests, nartural areas, moist wood, along creek banks, landscape, flower gardens

It can be used as herbs!










SO.... can we eat it now? 











Poisonous parts: ALL
Severity: FATAL if ingested


Aconite is a plant of the genus Aconitum.  Aconitine is a toxic derived from the Aconitum genus plant. Aconitine is high in toxicity and aconitine poisoning is usually caused by consuming Chinese herbal medicine or by eating aconite the plant itself.

 The usual causative agents of aconite poisoning are the Aconitines which comprise of aconitine, hypaconitine, jesaconitine and mesaconitine.) It is estimated the Lethal Dose, 50% (LD50) of aconitine for humans is 1-2mg/kg. 

This toxic acts on sodium channels in excitable membrane. The symptoms of aconitine poisoning are nausea, vomiting, numbness in limbs and arrhythmia. This poisoning often result in death due to cardiac arrest.

So how do we detect it in samples?


Stay tuned!

 

Instrument in determining aconitine: LC-MS

Liquid Chromatography - Mass Spectrometry


The instrument we used here to identify and quantify trace aconitine in deceased sample is LC-MS, which is HPLC (High Performance Liquid Chromatography) coupled with MS (Mass Spectrometry).
This method allows physical separation of components by HPLC and also mass analysis by MS. With this technique, high selectivity and sensitivity applications are performed. 

HPLC (high performance liquid chromatography)
A higher improved form of column chromatography. High pressure is used to force the solvent down the column, which makes it much faster. Physical separation of compounds is based on the interaction between the stationary phase and the analytes. HPLC allows smaller particle size for column packing material which gives a much larger surface area for better separation. 

MS (mass spectrometry)
An analytical method where components, after being separated by HPLC or other separation techniques, will undergo ionization to generate charged molecules/fragments and the identity of each component will be determined based on the distribution of the fragments' mass to charge ratios. 

In this way, accurate and precise quantitative and qualitative results can be achieved by coupled LC-MS (HPLC-MS).

As the mass spectrometry technique is new and foreign, this is a video behind to how it works.

Link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tOGM2gOHKPc



Summary:
Sample is auto injected into HPLC
Sample passes through column to be separated (usually by reversed phase)
Metabolites at the end of the column will enter the mass spectrometer
They are ionized and form positively charged ions
The ions are deflected and separated by electromagnetic field according to mass-to-charge ratios.
The beam of ions that passes through is detected electrically.



Saturday 26 January 2013 

LC-MS instrument to detect Aconitine in urine sample




HPLC: Waters 2690 instrument
XTerra RP18 column: 150 x 2.1-mm i.d., 3.5-µm particle size
Guard column: 10 x 2.1-mm i.d. 
Injection volume: 20µl
Mobile phase: (24 parts : 76 parts, v/v)
                    0.1% (v/v) formic acid in acetonitrile 
                    0.1% (v/v) formic acid in aqueous solution
Flow Rate: 0.2mL/min
Column temperature: 40 oC





MS: Micromass ZMD 4000 instrument (Waters)
Mode: electrospray ionization positive ion
Parameters:
                capillary potential 3.0 kV
                cone voltage 60V
                ion source temperature: 120 oC
                drying gas temperature: 350 oC
                nitrogen gas flow rate: 350 L/h
Measurements: selected ion monitoring mode

Friday 25 January 2013 

Preparation



Before analysis, we need several reagents.

  • ·         Mobile phase (formic acid of HPLC grade, acentonitrile of LC-MS grade)
  • ·         Methyllycaconitine (Internal Standard)
  • ·         Aconitines (Aconitine, Mesaconitine, Hypaconitine and Jesconitine)
  • ·         Deceased Urine Sample
  • ·         2mL of 0.025% (v/v) ammonia solution
  • ·     Aconitine Standards


For the Mobile phase,
Mix formic acid of 0.1% (v/v) with acetonitrile (solution 1). Mix formic acid of 0.1% (v/v) with aqueous solution (solution 2). Mix solution 1 with solution 2 to a ratio of (24:76, v/v).

For Urine sample,
We chose to take urine sample instead of serum sample as according to research, aconitines will not retain in serum after 24 hours of ingestion. However, it is still detectable in the urine after 23-62hours.

To prepare the sample, mix one milliliter of urine sample with 2.5ng of Methyllycaconitine (I.S) and 2 mL of 0.0025% (v/v) ammonia solution.

To prepare blank urine sample : Purify from deceased's urine sample using urine purification kits. Removal of nucleic acids and proteins.

For preparatation of standards: mix one mililiter of respective aconitine with 2.5ng of Methyllycaconitine (I.S) and 2 mL of 0.0025% (v/v) ammonia solution.

*Prepare 4 sets of urine sample as test will be run thrice and average result will be taken for a fair test. ( 3 urine samples from deceased, and a blank urine sample as control)

*Prepare 3 standards for each aconitines (aconitine, hypaconitine, jesconitine, mesaconitine) according to the table below:



 

Results- selected ion chromatograms

RESULTS
Blank urine sample












Spiked urine sample

 

Deceased urine sample






Qualitative analysis:

Mesaconitine, Aconitine and Jesaconitine identified in deceased's urine sample.

(IDENTITY APPROVED)









Quantitive analysis
Calculation of concentration of Mesaconitine, Aconitine, Jesaconitine in Urine sample

We calculate the (Ratio of standard aconitines/ Internal standard) by using the peak areas. With this results, we will be able to plot the calibration graph (Ratio of standard aconitines/ Internal standard against concentration of each of the Aconitines (Mesaconitine, Aconitine, Hypaconitine, Jesaconitine) by using the 3 standards.

After the calibration graph is plotted, we will have  linear equations for each of the 4 aconitines. This equation will be used to calculate the concentration of Mesaconitine, Aconitine, Jesaconitine in the deceased's urine sample. Thus, we will be able to quantitate trace amount of any of the aconitines present in the urine sample, and determine which is the highest concentration as well.





Thursday 24 January 2013 

PURSUING FURTHER...

FORENSIC REPORT- latest updates


A packet of Aconitine tampered sweets were found in Mary Rose's bag.... 




Did she put it herself??? Is she considering suicide? Or a homicide? 

POLICE REPORT

Suspect: Ramley Busher 


Relation to victim: Colleague working in ABC Enterprise 

Suspected motive: Being threaten by victim with evidence showing that he stole company's confidential information and selling it to other company. After paying a big sum of money, victim is still not satisfied and asked for more money. He did not want to be threatened anymore and decide to kill her. 

Plot: Sent a packet of victim's favorite sweet which is only available in Canada in the name of the victim's distant relative staying in Canada. The packet of sweets is already tampered with Aconitines. He then told her to meet at the hill for the transaction. He purposely did not reach in time, he knew the victim will have a few of that sweets while waiting. After ingesting at least 2 sweets, victim is poisoned and tried to call for help, but is helpless. Leaving her in the car waiting for her heart to stop. This is to purposely make police think that victim died of carbon monoxide poisoning.  

 

Case closed

28 JANUARY 2009: CASE CLOSED!

A case of HOMICIDE
After several investigations and trials, Busher has admitted to the murder of Mary Rose by aconitine poisoning. He will be charged with Lifelong Imprisonment. 

Remember..
JUSTICE WILL ALWAYS PREVAIL.

Wednesday 23 January 2013 

References

Scientific article used:

Fujita, Y., Terui, K., Fujita, M., Kakizaki, A., Sato, N., Oikawa, K., Aoki, H., & Takahashi, K. (2007, April ). Five cases of aconite poisoning: Toxicokinetics of aconitines. Retrieved from http://jat.oxfordjournals.org/content/31/3/132.full.pdf

Websites used:


httpen.wikipedia.orgwikiLiquid_chromatography%E2%80%93mass_spectrometry
http://www.allinterview.com/showanswers/115962.html
http://www.chemguide.co.uk/analysis/chromatography/hplc.html
http://www.jic.ac.uk/services/metabolomics/topics/lcms/why.htm
http://www.chemguide.co.uk/analysis/masspec/howitworks.html
http://www.ces.ncsu.edu/depts/hort/consumer/poison/Aconisp.htm

Case: Homicide or suicide? is powered by Blogspot and Gecko & Fly.
No part of the content or the blog may be reproduced without prior written permission.